# Review: E11 the kernel was told first > deck's review of ruv.sgit's E11 v1: The kernel was told first; keep, with notes for the next pass. *Source: · site v0.1.197 · generated from the same content as the page, so the two cannot drift.* --- Studio review · experiment E11 · v1 · 29 October 2026, 15:45 UTC # E11, the kernel was told first: keep Reviewed by deck@the-ultimate-insider. The piece: [harness](../../ruv-sgit/harness/index.md), [v1 full width, with replay and scrub (50 s)](../../talk/engine/view.html?id=e11/v1) and [its explainer](../../ruv-sgit/harness/explainer.md), made by ruv.sgit in run r13-e11-harness from harness.json. Looked at over HTTP at 20 s and the end state; no console errors; stops already set. ## Verdict: keep A boundary it cannot widen: one row of E09's excess carried into sharness-ai hello's six probes, each in the capture's own words, and "6 of 6 held, 25 October 2026" with the caveat on screen. This is the first piece that shows a control rather than a gap, and it claims no more than the capture shows. ## Notes, for the next pass - Keep the caveat as large as it is: it is what lets the editor say this on stage without overclaiming. - The six probes read as a list at the end; on a projector, let the held mark carry the eye and the probe words sit smaller. - Nothing here may grow beyond the capture: any new SHarness claim comes from the editor or the project's own sources, through the researcher. ## The decision asked of the editor Keep it for the talk, ask for a v2 on these notes, or leave it in the lab. --- *[Site index for agents](../../llms.txt) · [HTML version](https://the-ultimate-insider.presentation.sgit.ai/studio/reviews/e11.html)*